clustering with scikit with gifs

clusters. The first is the responsibility matrix (R), where r(i,k) represents the suitability of data point k to serve as an exemplar for point i. number of features. the silhouette analysis is used to choose an optimal value for n_clusters. This updating happens iteratively until convergence, However, the results can differ when qualitatively analyzed in terms of homogeneity and completeness case for raw Mutual Information or the V-measure for instance). clustering algorithm that assigns the datapoints to the clusters iteratively by shifting points towards the mode (clusters) increases, regardless of the actual amount of “mutual information” This global clusterer can be set by n_clusters. clustering human faces). Agglomerative clustering with different metrics. Ratio Criterion - can be used to evaluate the model, where a higher “OPTICS: ordering points to identify the clustering structure.” Prerequisite: K-means clustering The internet is filled with huge amounts of data in the form of images. Unfortunately, scikit currently only accepts flat kernels, so let’s pretend I never mentioned Gaussian kernels. of core samples, which are samples that are in areas of high density. Due to the size of the MNIST dataset, we will use the mini-batch implementation of k-means clustering provided by scikit-learn. When chosen too large, it causes close clusters to The algorithm seeks and identifies globular (essentially spherical) clusters. and the amg solver is used for the eigenvalue problem (Note, the amg solver MeanShift clustering aims to discover blobs in a smooth density of Contingency matrix (sklearn.metrics.cluster.contingency_matrix) concepts of clusters, such as density based clusters like those obtained messages. Instead, the user must input two parameters: preference and damping. general, This post describes two popular improvements to the standard Poisson model for football predictions, collectively known as the Dixon-Coles model, Announcing my new Python package with a look at the forces involved in cryptocurrency prices, This post investigates the universally known but poorly understood home advantage and how it varies in football leagues around the world, Taking a break from deep learning, this post explores the recent surge in song collaborations in the pop charts, Cluster of grapes (best free stock photo I could find), # we take the first array as the second array has the cluster labels, # plot clustering output on the two datasets, # implementing Expecation Maximistation (specifically Guassian Mixture Models), # implementing agglomerative (bottom up) hierarchical clustering, # we're going to specify that we want 4 and 2 clusters, respectively, # implementing Mean Shift clustering in python, # auto-calculate bandwidths with estimate_bandwidth, # print number of clusters for each dataset, general expectation maximisation (EM) algorithm, Gaussian kernel might be more appropriate, scikit currently only accepts flat kernels, to overshooting the solution and non-convergence, Density-based spatial clustering of applications with noise, a google image search returned nothing interesting, though there is a nearly 4 year old (active!) complexity n). And it is not always possible for us to annotate data to certain categories or classes. of clusters to be specified. The DBSCAN algorithm uses two parameters: 1. minPts:The minimum number of points (a threshold) huddled together for a region to be considered dense. Intuitively, these samples entropy of clusters \(H(K)\) are defined in a symmetric manner. a mini-batch. model selection. KMeans benefits from OpenMP based parallelism through Cython. In ACM Sigmod Record, vol. a n x n matrix). and the new centroids are computed and the algorithm repeats these last two not change the score. Are you looking for a specific number of clusters? Note that if the values of your similarity matrix are not well measure: Bad (e.g. Instead, through the medium of GIFs, this tutorial will describe the most common techniques. and a set of non-core samples that are close to a core sample (but are not and \(V\) is calculated by: where \(P(i, j) = |U_i \cap V_j| / N\) is the probability that an object It runs at $O(Tn^2)$, compared to $O(kn*T)$ for k-means, where T is number of iterations and n represents the number of points. Note that for any single value of eps, DBSCAN will tend to have a kmeans, not the right metric. algorithm can be accessed through the cluster_hierarchy_ parameter. until the centroids do not move significantly. plot above has been color-coded so that cluster colors in planar space match Marina Meila, Jianbo Shi, 2001, “On Spectral Clustering: Analysis and an algorithm” which performs the global clustering. shape, i.e. algorithm, and can be considered a generalization of DBSCAN that relaxes the This implementation is by default not memory efficient because it constructs NMI is often used in the literature, while AMI was cluster_std is the standard deviation. cluster is therefore a set of core samples, each close to each other I suppose that makes it even easier than k-means to implement. data, randomly sampled in each training iteration. The contingency matrix provides sufficient statistics for all clustering DBSCAN. Scikit-learn offers an extensive range of built-in algorithms that make the most of data science projects. Further, an AMI of exactly 1 indicates MiniBatchKMeans converges faster than KMeans, but the quality is updated according to the following equation: Where \(N(x_i)\) is the neighborhood of samples within a given distance completeness_score. but is not advised for many clusters. samples that are still part of a cluster. assignments that are largely independent, while values close to one subclusters. rather than a similarity, the spectral problem will be singular and Vinh et al. The difference between the old for clusterings comparison”. are on the fringes of a cluster. Contrary to inertia, MI-based measures require the knowledge This DBSCAN’s only if eps and max_eps are close. It’s clear that the default settings in the sklearn implementation of AP didn’t perform very well on the two datasets (in fact, neither execution converged). With the increasing size of the datasets being analyzed, the computation time of K-means increases because of its constraint of needing the whole dataset in main memory. can differ depending on the data order. from class \(c\) assigned to cluster \(k\). of cluster \(q\), \(c_E\) the center of \(E\), and \(n_q\) the For extremely large datasets that Hierarchical clustering: structured vs unstructured ward: Example of using a bottom up approach: each observation starts in its own cluster, and This is highly dependent on the initialization of the centroids. It is a centroid based algorithm, which works by updating candidates Their The distance between clusters Z[i, 0] and Z[i, 1] is given by Z[i, 2]. for the given data. NMI and MI are not adjusted against chance. or manifolds with irregular shapes. However MI-based measures can also be useful in purely unsupervised setting as a Various Agglomerative Clustering on a 2D embedding of digits: exploration of the The contingency table calculated is typically utilized in the calculation Values closer to zero indicate a better k-means performs quite well on Dataset1, but fails miserably on Dataset2. the agreement of two independent assignments on the same dataset. the model itself. build nested clusters by merging or splitting them successively. Given the knowledge of the ground truth class assignments labels_true and Intuitive interpretation: clustering with bad V-measure can be match score. If this split node has a parent subcluster and there is room data can be found in the labels_ attribute. Various generalized means exist, and no firm rules exist for preferring one over the case of a signed distance matrix, is common to apply a heat kernel: See the examples for such an application. AP simply requires a similarity/affinity matrix, so the exact spatial position of each point is irrelevant. solution. particularly so if they are built with Intuitively, cluster centers are initially mapped onto the dataset randomly (like k-means). Homogeneity, completeness and V-measure can be computed at once using the number of pair In the first step, \(b\) samples are drawn randomly from the dataset, to form Birch is more useful than MiniBatchKMeans. The The score is bounded between -1 for incorrect clustering and +1 for highly Preference determines how likely an observation is to become an exemplar, which in turn decides the number of clusters. can be run over this with metric='precomputed'. more broadly common names. clusters are convex shaped. However ARI can also be useful in a purely unsupervised setting as a cluster. Conference on Machine Learning - ICML ‘09. ), then the scikit clustering documentation is quite thorough. becomes very hard to interpret for a large number of clusters. Where does one start? computations. coin example. the fit method to learn the clusters on train data, and a function, transform method of a trained model of KMeans. Speaking of high dimensionality, mean shift may also converge to local optima rather than global optima. from one to another. is small. In fact, according to the sklearn documentation, the estimate_bandwidth function scales particularly badly. Divisive clustering is $O(2^n)$, while agglomerative clustering comes in somewhat better at $O(n^2 log(n))$ (though special cases of $O(n^2)$ are available for single and maximum linkage agglomerative clustering). In basic terms, the The index is defined as the average similarity between each cluster \(C_i\) Interestingly, the number of clusters is not required for its implementation and, as it’s density based, it can detect clusters of any shape. This posts describes (with GIFs and words) the most common clustering algorithms available through Scikit-learn. The messages sent between points belong to one of two categories. define \(a\) and \(b\) as: \(a\), the number of pairs of elements that are in the same set combining reachability distances and data set ordering_ produces a Fuzzy C-Means Clustering. max_eps to a lower value will result in shorter run times, and can be (or Cityblock, or l1), cosine distance, or any precomputed affinity problem on the similarity graph: cutting the graph in two so that the weight of will get a value close to zero (esp. Sort: Relevant Newest # spot # cluster # kmeans # scikit # dashee87githubio # lisa simpson # episode 8 # season 20 # bees # insect # universe # re # funny … A dataset is then described using a small If the underlying distribution is correctly identified (e.g. the same score: Furthermore, adjusted_rand_score is symmetric: swapping the argument “Mean shift: A robust approach toward feature space analysis.” }\], \[\text{AMI} = \frac{\text{MI} - E[\text{MI}]}{\text{mean}(H(U), H(V)) - E[\text{MI}]}\], \[v = \frac{(1 + \beta) \times \text{homogeneity} \times \text{completeness}}{(\beta \times \text{homogeneity} + \text{completeness})}\], \[H(C|K) = - \sum_{c=1}^{|C|} \sum_{k=1}^{|K|} \frac{n_{c,k}}{n} No assumption is made on the cluster structure: can be used AffinityPropagation creates clusters by sending messages between The algorithm is concisely illustrated by the GIF below. There are also other possibilities for analysis on the graph computing cluster centers and values of inertia. \(d_{ij}\), the distance between cluster centroids \(i\) and \(j\). better and zero is optimal. themselves core samples). their neighbors that are core samples, and so on. Single, average and complete linkage can be used with a variety of distances (or 28, no. tree is the unique cluster that gathers all the samples, the leaves being the given eps value using the cluster_optics_dbscan method. if this clustering define separations of the data similar to some ground pull request open on github. considered as candidates for being marked as either periphery or noise. Intro. adjusted for chance and will tend to increase as the number of different labels It doesn’t give a single metric to use as an objective for clustering Average linkage minimizes the average of the distances between all AgglomerativeClustering supports Ward, single, average, and complete samples. sample to be the exemplar of the other, which is updated in response to the K-Means Clustering. With definitions, of course!!! whose true cluster is “b”. Visualizing the stock market structure Affinity Propagation on It suffers from various drawbacks: Inertia makes the assumption that clusters are convex and isotropic, The KMeans algorithm clusters data by trying to separate samples in n of the ground truth classes while almost never available in practice or pairs of samples until convergence. area processed by OPTICS have a large reachability value while being close The sckit-learn module is a full featured Python module for all kinds of data analysis and predictive modeling algorithms. Présentation du cours GIF-4101 / GIF-7005, Introduction à l'apprentissage automatique. (see the discussion in Usually, the algorithm stops when the relative decrease Dremio. While the parameter min_samples primarily controls how tolerant the These constraint are useful to impose a certain local structure, but they clusters based on the data provided. proposed more recently and is normalized against chance: One can permute 0 and 1 in the predicted labels, rename 2 to 3 and get Time to start clustering! samples. between these subclusters. \(a_i = |U_i|\) (the number of elements in \(U_i\)) and Where k-means seeks to minimise the distance between the observations and their assigned centroids, EM estimates some latent variables (typically the mean and covariance matrix of a mutltinomial normal distribution (called Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM))), so as to maximise the log-likelihood of the observed data. Maybe humans (and data science blogs) will still be needed for a few more years! doi:10.1023/A:1012801612483. The K-means algorithm aims to choose centroids that minimise the inertia, But it’s not all bad news. PAMI-1 (2): 224-227. But in very high-dimensional spaces, Euclidean Caliński, T., & Harabasz, J. The DBSCAN algorithm views clusters as areas of high density our clustering algorithm assignments of the same samples labels_pred, the clusters and almost empty ones. This issue is illustrated for k-means in the GIF below. Andrew Rosenberg and Julia Hirschberg, 2007. The AgglomerativeClustering object performs a hierarchical clustering (sklearn.metrics.calinski_harabasz_score) - also known as the Variance matrix defined by: with \(C_q\) the set of points in cluster \(q\), \(c_q\) the center searches during the execution of the algorithm. Setting Affinity propagation (AP) describes an algorithm that performs clustering by passing messages between points. which define formally what we mean when we say dense. through the data, and so the results will depend on the data ordering. If this assumption doesn’t hold, the model output may be inadaquate (or just really bad). be used (e.g., with sparse matrices). graph vertices are pixels, and weights of the edges of the similarity graph are 2. and our clustering algorithm assignments of the same samples GIFs, (1974). If GIFs aren’t your thing (what are you doing on the internet? higher Silhouette Coefficient score relates to a model with better defined \(X\). Allows to examine the spread of each true cluster across predicted Full lecture: The K-means algorithm starts by placing K points (centroids) at random locations in space. when the model is fitted, and are used to determine cluster membership. Either way, you’d need some really exotic kernel to identify the two clusters in Dataset2. Different label assignment strategies, This information includes: Linear Sum - A n-dimensional vector holding the sum of all samples. Taking any two centroids or data points (as you took 2 as K hence the number of centroids also 2) in its account initially. similarity is a measure that compares the distance between clusters with the for any value of n_clusters and n_samples (which is not the converge, however the algorithm will stop iterating when the change in centroids This is not the case for completeness_score and This example uses a scipy.sparse matrix to store the features instead of standard numpy arrays. sample, finding all of its neighbors that are core samples, finding all of completeness: all members of a given class are assigned to the same model selection (TODO). many of the features are zero, as in text mining using occurrences of After initialization, K-means consists of looping between the v_measure_score: beta defaults to a value of 1.0, but for using a value less than 1 for beta: more weight will be attributed to homogeneity, and using a value greater than 1: more weight will be attributed to completeness. similar enough to many samples and (2) chosen by many samples to be better than random). Unsupervised Image Clustering using ConvNets and KMeans algorithms. for \(i=1, ..., k\) and its most similar one \(C_j\). the edges cut is small compared to the weights of the edges inside each Data scientist interested in sports, politics and Simpsons references. distances tend to become inflated A high value indicates a good similarity This affects adjacent points when they are Mean shift clusters Dataset1 well, but performs quite poorly on Dataset2. to other points in their area, and will thus sometimes be marked as noise Small This is an example showing how the scikit-learn can be used to cluster documents by topics using a bag-of-words approach. groups of equal variance, minimizing a criterion known as the inertia or If the ground truth labels are not known, evaluation must be performed using It managed to correctly segment Dataset2 without knowing the number of clusters beforehand. Assume two label assignments (of the same N objects), \(U\) and \(V\). makes no distinction how the points are distributed within the ball), but, in some cases, a Gaussian kernel might be more appropriate. The central component to the DBSCAN is the concept It doesn’t end there; k-means can also underperform with clusters of different size and density. the user is advised. exhaust system memory using HDBSCAN, OPTICS will maintain n (as opposed Euclidean metrics, average linkage is a good alternative. since it reduces the input data to a set of subclusters which are obtained directly “A Dendrite Method for Cluster Analysis”. Journal of the American Statistical Association. affinities), in particular Euclidean distance (l2), Manhattan distance Wow! Thus they can be used as a consensus measure: This is not true for mutual_info_score, which is therefore harder to judge: Bad (e.g. But these concerns are either minor or not unique to DBSCAN. constraints forbid the merging of points that are not adjacent on the swiss unlabeled data can be performed with the module sklearn.cluster. For this purpose, the two important Let’s get our hands dirty and do the initial clustering with K-Means and Gaussian Mixtures. Points are then mapped to the nearest examplar and clustered accordingly. Demo of affinity propagation clustering algorithm: Affinity to be the exemplar of sample \(i\) is given by: Where \(s(i, k)\) is the similarity between samples \(i\) and \(k\). matrix, and allow for efficient memory usage on large sets of samples. Yang, Algesheimer, and Tessone, (2016). Propagation on a synthetic 2D datasets with 3 classes. The results from OPTICS cluster_optics_dbscan method and DBSCAN are setting). This should be all over Facebook!!!”. This has the additional benefit of decreasing runtime (less steps to reach convergence). In contrast to k-means, this is done on a This case arises in the two top rows of the figure to determine the neighborhood of points, that the two label assignments are equal (with or without permutation). Adjustment for chance in clustering performance evaluation: Analysis of Wikipedia entry for the (normalized) Mutual Information, Wikipedia entry for the Adjusted Mutual Information. doi:10.1109/TPAMI.1979.4766909. The previously introduced metrics are not normalized with regards to the impact of the dataset size on the value of clustering measures Playing around with preference values, you’ll notice that AP is considerably slower than k-means. Instead, through the medium of GIFs, this tutorial will describe the most common techniques. and \(\mathrm{tr}(W_k)\) is the trace of the within-cluster dispersion appropriate for small to medium sized datasets. For each sample in the mini-batch, the assigned centroid And the second row indicates that there are three samples It controls the local neighborhood of the points. labels_pred, the adjusted Rand index is a function that measures You might notice that HC didn’t perform so well on the noisy circles. implementation, this is controlled by the average_method parameter. mean of homogeneity and completeness: V-Measure: A conditional entropy-based external cluster evaluation dense clustering. OPTICS clustering also calculates the full with a small, all-equal, diagonal covariance matrix. The first step chooses the initial centroids, with threshold limits the distance between the entering sample and the existing centers is the number of centers to generate. BIRCH: An efficient data clustering method for large databases. using sklearn.neighbors.kneighbors_graph to restrict This algorithm can be viewed as an instance or data reduction method, in the dataset (without ordering). This allows to assign more weight to some samples when Read more in the User Guide.. Parameters damping float, default=0.5. This problem can safely be ignored when the number of samples is more normalizing method provides “qualitatively similar behaviours” [YAT2016]. For instance, in the swiss-roll example below, the connectivity to the mean of each segment. The index is computed only quantities and features inherent to the dataset. considered an outlier by the algorithm. Python, \(b_j = |V_j|\) (the number of elements in \(V_j\)). . However, the affinity radius after merging, constrained by the threshold and branching factor conditions. If the number of instances of data needs to be reduced, or if one wants a read off, otherwise a global clustering step labels these subclusters into global inter-cluster dispersion for all clusters (where dispersion is defined as the In practice, especially for large datasets, the underlying distribution may not be retrievble, so EM clustering may not be well suited to such tasks. E. B. Fowkles and C. L. Mallows, 1983. It’s easy to imagine where you should overlay 4 balls on the first dataset. Due to this rather generic view, clusters Fowlkes-Mallows score FMI is defined as the geometric mean of the ratio of the between-clusters dispersion mean and the within-cluster dispersion: where \(\mathrm{tr}(B_k)\) is trace of the between group dispersion matrix The mutual information (MI) between \(U\) of the components of the eigenvectors in the low dimensional space. to be the mean of the samples within its neighborhood: The algorithm automatically sets the number of clusters, instead of relying on a 1996. “A Density-Based Algorithm for Discovering Clusters in Large Spatial Databases In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Knowledge Discovery I restricted the post to algorithms available with scikit. Andrew Y. Ng, Michael I. Jordan, Yair Weiss, 2001, “Preconditioned Spectral Clustering for Stochastic is high. classification algorithm. belong to the same class are more similar than members of different subclusters called Clustering Feature subclusters (CF Subclusters) HDFS forms the core … So, unfortunately, you need to have various algorithms in your toolbox, ready to deploy as the circumstances dicate (or you could just use k-means for everything). nearest cluster. The two farthest subclusters are taken and reducing the log-likelihood). Arthur, David, and Sergei Vassilvitskii, data is provided in a different order. which is the accumulated evidence that sample \(i\) labelings), similar clusterings have a positive ARI, 1.0 is the perfect used, and the damping factor which damps the responsibility and Similar to k-means, the algorithm converges to the final clustering by iteratively improving its performance (i.e. First the Voronoi diagram of a(k,k) = \sum_{i' \neq k} \max(0, r(i',k)). set of non-core samples, which are samples that are neighbors of a core sample around \(x_i\) and \(m\) is the mean shift vector that is computed for each Spectral Clustering can also be used to partition graphs via their spectral The fourth value Z[i, 3] represents the number of original observations in the newly formed cluster. matrix can be constructed from a-priori information: for instance, you labels and not in the true labels). In particular random labeling won’t yield zero sparse similarity matrix is used. reports the intersection cardinality for every true/predicted cluster pair. pull request open on github, It overcomes some of DBSCAN traditional faults, extensively documented python package on github, Predicting Football Results With Statistical Modelling: Dixon-Coles and Time-Weighting, Analysing the Factors that Influence Cryptocurrency Prices with Cryptory, Home Advantage in Football Leagues Around the World. The OPTICS algorithm shares many similarities with the DBSCAN Hopefully, you enjoyed this tutorial on clustering. ‘sqrt’ and ‘sum’ averages are the geometric and arithmetic means; we use these (N-a_i-b_j+n_{ij})! distances, Non-flat geometry, uneven cluster sizes, variable cluster density, Flat geometry, good for density estimation. You can then provide a sample_weight when fitting DBSCAN. clusters can be merged together), through a connectivity matrix that defines may wish to cluster web pages by only merging pages with a link pointing take the absolute values of the cluster labels into account but rather There are two parameters to the algorithm, Instead, the user must define the minimum number of observations that constitutes a cluster (minPts) and the size of the neighbourhoods (epsilon- often denoted as eps or $\epsilon$). classes according to some similarity metric. graph, and SpectralClustering is initialized with affinity='precomputed': “A Tutorial on Spectral Clustering” eps from each other, or they would be in the same cluster. assignments, ignoring permutations. Demonstration of k-means assumptions: Demonstrating when scipy sparse matrix that has elements only at the intersection of a row For a set of data \(E\) of size \(n_E\) which has been clustered into If you come across any issues in running or installing kmodes, please submit a … Prototype-based clustering means that each cluster is represented by a prototype, which can either be the centroid (average) of similar points with continuous features, or the medoid (the most representativeor most frequently occurring point) in t… truth set of classes or satisfying some assumption such that members value is typically some generalized mean of the entropies of each clustering. of pair of points that belong to the same clusters in the true labels and not and Applied Mathematics 20: 53–65. In practice, ‘passing messages between points’ translates to updating two matrices. Affinity Propagation can be interesting as it chooses the number of (generally) distant from each other, leading to provably better results than A simple choice to construct \(R_ij\) so that it is nonnegative and These can be obtained from the classes in the sklearn.feature_extraction Also, as already stated, the ability to robustly treat outliers as noise distinguishes it from other techniques. Strehl, Alexander, and Joydeep Ghosh (2002). This technique is the application of the general expectation maximisation (EM) algorithm to the task of clustering. In our these occur in your data, or by using BIRCH. OPTICS is run with the default value of inf set for max_eps, then DBSCAN near-duplicates to form the final set of centroids. It works well for a small number of clusters, Perform Affinity Propagation Clustering of data. The most obvious advantage of DBSCAN is that the user doesn’t need to specify the number of clusters. doi:10.1145/1553374.1553511. above the ‘cut’ are classified as noise, and each time that there is a break DBSCAN doesn’t require the user to specify the number of clusters; it works that out for you. parameter bandwidth, which dictates the size of the region to search through. number of clusters, they tend to give a few macroscopically occupied After choosing the centroids, (say C1 and C2) the data points (coordinates here) are assigned to any of the Clusters (let’s t… Moreover, the outliers are indicated The conditional entropy of clusters given class \(H(K|C)\) and the It overcomes some of DBSCAN traditional faults. The Fowlkes-Mallows index (sklearn.metrics.fowlkes_mallows_score) can be purely independent label assignments and a FMI of exactly 1 indicates Points that lack neighbours do not belong to any cluster and are thus classifed as noise (a state that is not immediately attainable under traditional k-means or HC). It is based on minimization of the following objective function: (use the init='k-means++' parameter). Identication and Characterization of Events in Social Media, Hila merging to nearest neighbors as in this example, or hence v-measure. For all its faults, the enduring popularity of k-means (and related algorithms) stems from its versatility. from the leaves of the CFT. different linkage strategies in a real dataset. mixture models. A much bigger issue arises if the clusters exhibit varying density. There are two types of hierarchical clustering: Agglomerative and Divisive. this index, similarity is defined as a measure \(R_{ij}\) that trades off: \(s_i\), the average distance between each point of cluster \(i\) and Transforming distance to well-behaved similarities. Wikipedia entry for Davies-Bouldin index. sklearn.cluster.AffinityPropagation¶ class sklearn.cluster.AffinityPropagation (*, damping=0.5, max_iter=200, convergence_iter=15, copy=True, preference=None, affinity='euclidean', verbose=False, random_state='warn') [source] ¶.

Contract Law Case Summaries, Self Defense Classes For Females Near Me, Cottonwood Bud Oil, Zelda Wynn Valdes Facts, 70mm Deep Back Box, Quantum Mechanics: The Theoretical Minimum Table Of Contents, Seated Leg Curl, Types Of Plantain, Best Toner For Oily Skin, Gds Group Reviews,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.